Are Impact Resistant Shingles Worth It for Utah Homes?
Roof Installation

Are Impact Resistant Shingles Worth It for Utah Homes?

•Published: 05 SEP, 2026

Are Impact Resistant Shingles Worth It for Utah Homes?

Are impact resistant shingles worth it? For most homes along the Wasatch Front that are due for a new roof, yes, when hail, wind-blown debris or overhanging trees are a realistic risk and the owner plans to stay for years. They cost more than standard shingles, and in return they are built to resist cracking when struck, which means fewer repairs over the life of the roof. They are not hail proof, and the value depends on the rating class, the insurer and the exposure of the house.
This guide explains how the ratings work, how Class 3 and Class 4 differ, what the rating does not cover and how to decide.

What are impact resistant shingles?

They are asphalt shingles made to absorb a blow without cracking. The difference is in the materials, not in how they look from the street.
  • A heavier or reinforced mat at the core of the shingle
  • Asphalt blended with polymers in many products, which keeps it flexible, especially in cold weather
  • In some designs, a reinforcing layer on the back of the shingle
  • The same architectural profiles and colors as standard shingles
  • Installation by the same methods, following the manufacturer's instructions
Hail harms a standard shingle by bruising the mat and knocking off the granules that shield the asphalt from the sun. A shingle that flexes on impact is less likely to crack through.

How are impact resistant shingles rated?

By a laboratory test known as UL 2218. Steel balls of increasing size are dropped onto the installed shingle, twice on the same spot, and the back of the shingle is then checked for cracks.
  • Class 1: withstands a 1.25-inch steel ball
  • Class 2: withstands a 1.5-inch steel ball
  • Class 3: withstands a 1.75-inch steel ball
  • Class 4: withstands a 2-inch steel ball, the highest rating
The class appears on the product wrapper and in the manufacturer's literature. The rating describes resistance to cracking in a controlled test. Real hail varies in hardness, shape and speed, and wind adds to its force, so a rating is a comparison between products and not a guarantee.

What is the difference between Class 3 and Class 4 shingles?

The size of the impact each one passed. Comparing Class 3 vs Class 4 shingles, Class 4 survived the largest test ball and Class 3 the next size down.
  • Both are a clear step up from unrated shingles
  • Class 4 is the rating most insurers refer to when they offer a discount
  • Class 4 products usually cost more than Class 3
  • Class 3 covers the smaller hail that makes up most storms
  • Either one has to be installed to the manufacturer's specifications to perform as rated
North Point Roofing LLC states on its site that it installs architectural asphalt shingles with a Class 3 impact rating as part of its roofing installation service. Ask which class each product in your estimate carries, and ask to see it in the manufacturer's data sheet.

What does the rating not protect against?

It does not make a roof immune to storms. Knowing the limits prevents disappointment later.
  • Very large or wind-driven hail can damage any shingle
  • Granule loss and cosmetic marks can still occur without cracking
  • Flashing, vents, skylights and gutters can be dented or broken even when the shingles hold
  • Some insurance policies exclude cosmetic damage, which matters more when the roof resists functional damage
  • Wind resistance is a separate rating from impact resistance
  • Old age still wears out an impact resistant roof
After a severe storm, have the roof checked even if it carries a high rating. Damage to the metal parts and the roof penetrations is often what lets water in.

Is there an impact resistant shingles insurance discount?

Sometimes. An impact resistant shingles insurance discount is offered by some insurers in hail-prone areas, usually for Class 4 roofs, and the terms vary widely.
  • Ask your agent whether a discount exists in Utah for your policy and which class qualifies
  • Ask what proof is required, such as a certificate or invoice naming the product
  • Ask whether accepting the discount changes how cosmetic damage is covered
  • Keep the product wrappers, the invoice and photos of the installation
  • Recheck when you change insurers, since programs differ
Do not count on a discount until your own insurer confirms it in writing. Treat it as a possible bonus on top of the main benefit, which is a roof less likely to need repair.

When do impact resistant shingles make the most sense?

When the roof is being replaced anyway and the exposure is real. Hail resistant roofing in Utah earns its cost most clearly in these situations.
  • The house sits in an open area exposed to storms and canyon winds
  • The neighborhood has had hail claims in recent years
  • Trees overhang the roof and drop branches
  • You plan to keep the house long enough to benefit
  • Your insurer rewards the upgrade
  • The roof is steep or tall, which makes every future repair more costly
They make less sense on a house you expect to sell soon, or where the budget would be better spent correcting ventilation, decking or flashing problems first. Homeowners weighing the top level of impact and weather resistance sometimes compare shingles with metal, covered in the company's article on the benefits of metal roofing.

Frequently asked questions about impact resistant shingles

Do impact resistant shingles look different from regular shingles?

No. They come in the same architectural styles and colors as standard shingles. The differences are in the mat, the asphalt blend and sometimes a backing layer, none of which can be seen once the roof is installed.

How much more do impact resistant shingles cost?

They cost more than standard architectural shingles, and Class 4 usually more than Class 3. The difference depends on the product and the size of the roof, so ask for the estimate to show both options side by side.

Do impact resistant shingles last longer?

They can, because they resist the cracking and bruising that shorten the life of a roof in storm-prone areas. Their lifespan still depends on ventilation, installation quality, sun exposure and maintenance, as with any shingle.

Can impact resistant shingles be installed over old shingles?

A full tear-off is the better practice. Impact ratings are tested on a solid deck, and a soft layer of old shingles underneath can reduce performance. The process is described on the company's page for tear-off and new roof installation.

Talk to North Point Roofing LLC about your new roof

North Point Roofing LLC is a roofing contractor based in Ogden, UT that offers roof installation, tear-off and replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, cedar shakes, TPO and heat cable installation. It serves Ogden, North Ogden, South Ogden, Farmington, Bountiful and Centerville. To compare shingle options for your home and request a free estimate, call 385-298-2310 or contact North Point Roofing LLC.