Roof Overlay vs Tear Off: Which Is Right for Your Home?
In the roof overlay vs tear off decision, a tear-off is the better choice for most homes. An overlay puts new shingles on top of the old ones, which lowers the labor and disposal cost at first. A tear-off removes everything down to the wood deck, so damaged boards can be replaced, new underlayment and flashing installed, and the new shingles laid on a flat, solid surface. In snow country the extra weight of a second layer is one more reason to remove the old roof.
This guide explains what each method involves, when an overlay is ruled out, its drawbacks, the few cases where it can be reasonable and how to compare the two.
What is a roof overlay?
A roof overlay, also called a layover roof or a reroof, is a new layer of asphalt shingles installed directly over the existing layer. Nothing is removed except, in some cases, the ridge caps and vents.
- The old shingles stay in place and act as the base
- New shingles are nailed through the old layer into the deck
- Disposal is limited, since little is taken off
- The job is usually faster
- The deck, the underlayment and most of the flashing are not seen or renewed
That last point is the source of nearly every objection to overlays. The parts of a roof that keep water out when shingles fail are the ones an overlay leaves untouched.
What does a full roof tear-off include?
A full roof tear-off removes the old roofing down to the deck and rebuilds the system in layers. North Point Roofing LLC describes its process as stripping the old shingles to the deck, inspecting the structure, and repairing or reinforcing damaged trusses and plywood before anything new goes on.
- Removal of all old shingles, underlayment and worn flashing
- Inspection of the deck, with soft or delaminated boards replaced
- Ice and water barrier at the eaves, valleys and penetrations
- New underlayment across the roof
- New flashing, drip edge, vents and pipe boots
- New shingles fastened into a clean, flat deck
- Cleanup and disposal of the old material
The company's page on tear-off and new roof installation states its view plainly: tearing off the old roof first is usually the best choice, and at times it is the only choice.
Can you put new shingles over old shingles?
Sometimes, within limits. Whether you can put new shingles over old shingles depends on the building code where you live and on the condition of the existing roof.
- Building codes commonly allow no more than two layers of asphalt shingles
- A roof that already has two layers must be torn off
- Curled, buckled or badly worn shingles are not a suitable base
- A deck that is wet, soft or sagging rules out an overlay
- Wood shakes, slate and tile cannot be covered with asphalt shingles in the usual way
- Some shingle manufacturers restrict or condition their warranties on overlays
Requirements vary by city and county. Confirm the rules with your local building department before accepting a quote for an overlay.
What are the drawbacks of an overlay?
The drawbacks are hidden damage, added weight and a shorter-lived result.
- Rotted or delaminated decking stays hidden and keeps deteriorating
- Leaks that exist under the old layer are covered, not fixed
- Old flashing is reused or worked around, and flashing is where most leaks start
- Ice and water barrier cannot be added at the eaves, which matters where ice dams form
- The second layer adds permanent weight to the structure
- Bumps and curls in the old layer show through, and the new shingles lie less flat
- Heat held between the layers can age the new shingles faster
- The next replacement requires removing two layers, at a higher cost
Weight deserves attention in northern Utah, where the roof must also carry snow. The factors that affect a roof's capacity are explained in the company's article on how much snow a roof can hold.
When might an overlay be reasonable?
In a narrow set of cases, when the existing roof is a single, flat, sound layer and the budget is the deciding factor.
- Only one layer is in place and it lies flat
- There are no leaks, stains or soft spots, confirmed from the attic
- The deck is known to be in good condition
- The flashing is sound or can be properly replaced
- Local code and the shingle manufacturer both allow it
- The owner understands that the next roof will cost more to remove
Even then, the savings are smaller than they first appear, because the questions a tear-off answers stay open. Many roofers decline overlays for that reason. Ask any contractor who proposes one how the deck and flashing were evaluated.
How should you compare an overlay with a tear-off?
Compare what you get for the life of the roof, not just the first price.
- Ask for both options in writing if an overlay is allowed, with the same shingle
- Compare the warranty offered on each
- Ask what happens if damaged decking is found, and how it is priced
- Ask whether ice and water barrier, underlayment, drip edge and flashing are included
- Consider how long you plan to own the house
- Remember that buyers and home inspectors often view a second layer as a negative
A tear-off costs more because it includes more: disposal, deck repairs, underlayment and new flashing. Those are the items that decide how long the new roof stays dry. The steps are outlined on the company's roofing installation page.
Frequently asked questions about roof overlays and tear-offs
How can I tell how many layers of shingles my roof has?
Look at the edge of the roof at the eave or the rake, where the layers are visible in profile. A thick or stepped edge suggests more than one layer. A roofer can confirm it by lifting the shingles at the edge or checking around a vent.
Is an overlay cheaper than a tear-off?
At first, yes, because it avoids most of the removal and disposal work. Over time the difference narrows or reverses: an overlaid roof tends to wear sooner, and the next replacement requires taking off two layers.
Does a roof overlay void the shingle warranty?
It can limit it. Manufacturers set their own conditions for installation over existing shingles, and some coverage applies only to roofs installed over a clean deck. Read the warranty for the specific product before deciding.
How long does a tear-off add to a roof replacement?
For most single-family homes, removing the old roof is done on the first day or two of the project. Weather, the number of existing layers and any deck repairs can extend it.
Talk to North Point Roofing LLC about replacing your roof
North Point Roofing LLC is a roofing contractor based in Ogden, UT that offers tear-off and new roof installation, roof repair, metal roofing, cedar shakes, TPO and heat cable installation. It serves Ogden, North Ogden, South Ogden, Farmington, Bountiful and Centerville. To have your existing roof and deck evaluated and request a free estimate, call 385-298-2310 or contact North Point Roofing LLC.
