How to Tell If Your Roof Has Hail Damage After a Storm
To tell if your roof has hail damage, start on the ground: look for dents in gutters, downspouts and metal vents, piles of shingle granules at the downspouts, and damaged window screens, siding or outdoor equipment. Those signs show that the hail was big enough to hurt the roof. Damage on the shingles themselves, such as bruises, cracks and spots where granules are missing, is best confirmed by a roofer on the roof.
This guide explains what to check safely after a storm, what a roof inspection looks for, how damage differs by roofing material and what to do next.
Why does hail damage matter if the roof is not leaking?
Hail damage matters because it often does not leak right away. A hailstone can crack the mat of a shingle or knock off the granules that protect it from the sun. The roof stays dry for now, but the damaged spots age faster and can let water in months later, often during snowmelt.
In Northern Utah, summer thunderstorms can bring hail, and a roof that was hit in July faces freeze-thaw cycles a few months later. Finding damage early gives you time to repair it before winter.
What can you check safely from the ground?
You can learn a lot without climbing a ladder. Walk around the house after the storm has passed and look for:
- Dents or dings in gutters, downspouts and gutter guards
- Dented roof vents, flashing or chimney caps, visible from the yard
- Piles of dark granules at the bottom of downspouts or on the patio
- Shingles that look spotted, missing or out of place
- Cracked or chipped siding, torn window screens and dented window frames
- Dents on air conditioning units, mailboxes, cars and outdoor furniture
Take photos of everything with the date, including hailstones next to a coin or a ruler if you can do so safely. Do not walk on the roof yourself: wet, damaged shingles are slippery and steep roofs are dangerous.
What does hail damage look like on shingles?
On asphalt shingles, hail damage usually looks like random dark spots where granules were knocked off. Up close, a roofer looks for:
- Bruises: soft spots that feel like a bruised apple when pressed
- Cracks or fractures in the shingle, sometimes on the underside only
- Exposed mat or fiberglass where the granules are gone
- Damaged or loosened shingle edges and broken seals
- Damage that appears in a random pattern, not in neat lines
Wear from age shows as an even loss of granules across the roof. Hail damage is scattered and often concentrated on the slopes that faced the storm.
How does hail affect other roofing materials?
Each material shows hail differently:
- Metal roofing: dents are common; many are cosmetic, but sharp impacts can damage seams or coatings
- Cedar shakes: fresh splits with sharp, light-colored edges and dents in the wood
- Flat roofs and TPO: punctures or bruises in the membrane, which can be hard to see
- Impact-resistant shingles: tested to resist hail of a given size, but very large stones can still damage them
Our post on whether impact resistant shingles are worth it explains what those ratings mean.
What should you do right after a hail storm?
Act in a clear order so you protect the house and keep a record:
- Check the attic and ceilings for new stains or drips
- If there is an active leak, protect belongings and contain the water
- Photograph damage around the house, with dates
- Call a roofer for an inspection
- Contact your insurance company to ask about your coverage and how to file a claim
Ask the roofer for photos of any damage found on the roof. North Point Roofing LLC says on its home page that it documents every phase of its installations with before-and-after photos, and offers storm damage and roofing repair.
When does hail damage mean a new roof?
Hail damage means a new roof when the damage is spread across many slopes, when the roof was already near the end of its life, or when repairs would not blend with the old shingles. Small, isolated damage can often be repaired. A roofer should explain which option fits and why. When replacement is the answer, North Point describes its full tear-off and new roof installation, which strips the old shingles down to the deck and inspects it before the new roof goes on.
Frequently asked questions about hail damage on roofs
What size hail damages a roof?
It depends on the roof's age, material and condition. Larger hail is more likely to cause damage, but even smaller stones can harm an older roof. The size of dents on gutters and vents gives a useful clue.
Can hail damage a roof without any leaks?
Yes. Hail can crack shingles and remove granules without causing a leak right away. The damaged areas wear faster and may start leaking months later, so an inspection after a strong storm is worthwhile.
Should I call my insurance company or a roofer first?
Many homeowners have a roofer inspect first so they know whether there is damage to report. Your policy decides how and when to file, so read it or ask your insurer about deadlines and the steps they require.
How long after a storm can I file a hail claim?
That depends on your policy. Some policies set time limits for reporting damage. Check your policy or call your insurer soon after the storm instead of waiting.
Have your roof inspected by North Point Roofing LLC
North Point Roofing LLC is a roofing contractor based in Ogden, UT that repairs and replaces residential roofs, including shingle, metal, cedar shake and TPO roofing. It serves Ogden, North Ogden, South Ogden, Farmington, Bountiful, Centerville and other Northern Utah communities. If a storm has passed over your home, call 385-298-2310 or contact North Point Roofing LLC for a free estimate.
